State Theocracy Perspective: Comparative Study of Caliphate and Vatican Church Governmental System

Khairunnas Khairunnas, Maudy Noor Fadhlia

Abstract


This paper presents a rigorous comparative study of the Islamic Caliphate and the Vatican City State, which operates under the governance of the Roman Catholic Church. Both institutions are anchored in authoritative theological doctrine, yet their historical evolution, mechanisms of legitimation, and global reception have unfolded in sharply contrasting manners. The Caliphate, conceived as the apex of Islamic authority uniting political and spiritual oversight, underwent a sequence of crises, culminating in the formal abolition in 1924, resulting in an enduring contest over its contemporary significance. The Vatican, by contrast, has displayed remarkable durability, its papal leadership securing a distinctive role in secular diplomacy and international governance, sustained by a coherent apparatus that transcends the territorial confines. The core finding is that the Vatican’s enduring stability stems from its successful transformation of theological mandate into widely recognized diplomatic legitimacy and transnational soft power. This contrasts with the Caliphate’s decline, which was accelerated by its structural entanglement with territorial governance and military power, leading to perceptions of it as an anachronism. This study contributes a novel cross-civilizational analytical template, treating both entities as theocratic formations. It compares their historical processes, modes of theological authority, and patterns of political reception within their respective polities. The principal innovation resides in this comparative frame, which illuminates how religion is mobilized as institutional power and addresses the contrasting degrees of global endorsement each system receives.Employing a qualitative, descriptive-analytical framework grounded in a multiple case study methodology, this inquiry seeks to advance religious political theory by unraveling the nuanced interplay between religious institutions and the apparatus of the state.

Keywords


theocracy; caliphate; vatican; comparative politics; religious legitimacy.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Ahmad Akbar, I., Lilawati, E., Rohmah, H., Kh, U. A., Wahab, H., & Jombang, I. (2025). THE LEGITIMACY OF THE CALIPHATE AS A STATE SYSTEM (A Hermeneutic Study of The Term Khalifah in the Quran). Journal of Islamic Studies, 2(1). https://doi.org/10.54622/aijis.v2i1.414

Bunzel, C. (2015). From Paper State to Caliphate: The Ideology of the Islamic State.

Darajat, Z. (2019). Probematika Agama Dan Negara: Perspektif Sejarah. Buletin Al-Turas, 25(1), 75–91. https://doi.org/10.15408/bat.v25i1.8682

Doris, Y. E. I., & Sitohang, L. G. (2023). Demokrasi Di Tengah Konflik Kepentingan Masyarakat Sipil Dan Pemerintah Dalam Kasus Wadas-Jawa Tengah. Jurnal Ilmiah Falsafah Jurnal Kajian Filsafat Teologi Dan Humaniora, 8(2), 42–51. https://doi.org/10.37567/jif.v8i2.1193

Duffy, E. (2015). Saints and sinners: A history of the popes. Yale University Press.

Hallaq, W. (2018). Restating orientalism: A critique of modern knowledge. Columbia University Press.

Hamdi, S., Rahmawadi, I., Nasrullah, A., Riduan, I. M., & Prasojo, Z. H. (2023). Jamaah Tabligh Dan Pergeseran Identitas Politik Keagamaan Pada Pemilihan Presiden 2019 Di Lombok, Nusa Tenggara Barat. Harmoni, 22(1), 143–166. https://doi.org/10.32488/harmoni.v1i22.661

Handoyo, H., & Supriyanto, S. (2023). Relasi Agama Dan Negara Perspektif Pemikiran Islam Dalam Konteks Ke Indonesiaan. Islamadina Jurnal Pemikiran Islam, 24(2), 245. https://doi.org/10.30595/islamadina.v24i2.14222

Harianto, G. P. (2023). Ancilla Theologiae: Hubungan, Kontribusi, Dan Tantangan Bagi Kehidupan Masyarakat Kristen Di Era Global. Excelsis Deo Jurnal Teologi Misiologi Dan Pendidikan, 7(2). https://doi.org/10.51730/ed.v7i2.135

Ihsan, N. A. (2022). Konsep Ekonomi Islam Pada Masa Bani Umayyah, Bani Abbasiyah, Dan Turki Utsmani. https://doi.org/10.31219/osf.io/76k3t

Iqbal, A. M. (2016). Varied Impacts of Globalization on Religion in a Contemporary Society. Religió Jurnal Studi Agama-Agama, 6(2), 207–229. https://doi.org/10.15642/religio.v6i2.604

Kennedy, H. (2022). The Prophet and the age of the Caliphates: the Islamic Near East from the sixth to the eleventh century. Routledge.

Margittay-Mészáros, Á. (2024). PARADIGMS IN THE INTERNATIONAL LEGAL PERSONALITY OF THE HOLY SEE FROM THE CONGRESS OF VIENNA TO THE LATERAN PACT. Russian Law Journal, 12(2), 3206–3213.

Meriyati, M. (2018). Perkembangan Ekonomi Islam Pada Masa Daulah Abbasiyah. Islamic Banking Jurnal Pemikiran Dan Pengembangan Perbankan Syariah, 4(1), 45–56. https://doi.org/10.36908/isbank.v4i1.54

Mubarak, H., & Razak, A. (2018). Pandangan Jamaah Tabligh Dan Salafi Terhadap Khilafah, Demokrasi, Dan Monarki (Satu Tinjauan Di Jambi). Al-Risalah, 15(02), 241–256. https://doi.org/10.30631/al-risalah.v15i02.364

Murphy, J. (2025, November 6). The Impact of Pope Francis: The Pope as a Moral Leader on the Global Stage. https://www.ethicsandinternationalaffairs.org/online-exclusives/the-impact-of-pope-francis-the-pope-as-a-moral-leader-on-the-global-stage

Oceania, S. A., Robiansyah, F., Alfalah, M., & Danuarta, V. Y. (2024). Analisis Penggunaan Politik Identitas Berdasarkan Al-Quran Dan Hadist. Tafáqquh Jurnal Penelitian Dan Kajian Keislaman, 12(1), 131–152. https://doi.org/10.52431/tafaqquh.v12i1.2753

Pew Research Center. (2020, March 19). Catholic Population on the Rise Globally, Especially in Africa.

Ramadhan, F., Wahid, D. N., & Nizam, N. (2023). Hubungan Negara Dan Agama: Telaah Hukum Dan Putusan Pengadilan. Jurnal Asosiasi Pengajar Hukum Tata Negara Hukum Administrasi Negara (Japhtn-Han), 2(1), 1–36. https://doi.org/10.55292/japhtnhan.v2i1.58

Robinson, C. F. (2018). Islamic historiography (Vol. 1). Cambridge University Press.

Romanko, A. (2024). The governing system of the Vatican City State under the Fundamental Law of the Vatican City State of 2023. Journal of Modern Science, 60, 813–827. https://doi.org/10.13166/jms/197003

Rubaidi, R., & Setianingsih, D. (2021). Politik Identitas Islam Indonesia Kontemporer: Radikalisme Islam Versus Moderatisme Islam Dalam Politik Elektoral Pilpres 2019 (Contemporary Indonesian Islamic Identity Politics: Islamic Radicalism Versus Islamic Moderatism in the 2019 Presidential Electi. Potret Pemikiran, 25(2), 149. https://doi.org/10.30984/pp.v25i2.1593

Setyawati, V. D., & Purbiyati, Y. S. (2021). Etika Akuntansi Dalam Pelaporan Keuangan Gereja Katolik Redemptor Mundi Surabaya. Jad Jurnal Riset Akuntansi & Keuangan Dewantara, 4(2), 105–110. https://doi.org/10.26533/jad.v4i2.889

Tawa, A. B., Meja, M. B., & Yogalianti, L. (2022). Partisipasi Orang Muda Katolik Dalam Kehidupan Rohani Di Paroki Santo Vinsensius a Paulo Batulicin. InTheos, 1(3), 92–99. https://doi.org/10.56393/intheos.v1i3.532

Tlonaen, N. M., & Saingo, Y. A. (2023). Peran Ideologi Pancasila Dalam Pembentukan Perilaku Anti Ekstremisme Agama. Jurnal Multidisiplin West Science, 2(12), 1040–1050. https://doi.org/10.58812/jmws.v2i12.810

Wilson, A. R., & Djupe, P. A. (2020). Communicating in good faith? Dynamics of the Christian right agenda. Politics and Religion, 13(2), 385–414.

Zagano, P. (2017). The Original Bishops: Office and Order in the First Christian Communities. By Alistair C. Stewart. Grand Rapids, MI: Baker Academic, 2014. xx+ 394 pages. $50.00. Horizons, 44(1), 210–211.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.33373/jtp.v9i2.8165

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


 

Flag Counter

Web Analytics

View JTP Statistic

 

Office:

Department of Government Studies, Faculty of Social and Political Sciences, Universitas Riau Kepulauan

unit E

Jl. Pahlawan No. 99, Bukit Tempayan, Batu Aji, Kota Batam

Contact: (0778) 39275

e-mail: jurnaltriaspolitika2017@gmail.com 

________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________________

 

In Cooperation with:                     Powered By: 

   

 

 

Lisensi Creative Commons

Jurnal Trias Politika (JTP) is licensed under a Lisensi Creative Commons Atribusi 4.0 Internasional.