Exploring the Conundrum of Law Enforcement versus Personal Dignity: Constitutional Court Judges' Dissenting Opinions in Indonesia

Rizal Khadafi, Nurul Satria Abdi

Abstract


The Republic of Indonesia's Constitutional Court (MK RI) garnered significant public attention during the 2024 elections due to two contentious rulings it rendered. The age restriction for presidential and vicepresidential candidates was the subject of the first ruling, while challenges to the election results were the subject of the second. It's interesting to note that a number of judges have expressed opinions that differ from the rulings in these two contentious decisions, a fact known as dissenting opinions. This study intends to investigate the legal foundation of dissenting opinions and the legal ramifications of such decisions using qualitative approaches, bolstered by document analysis, case studies, and jurisprudence analysis. This study concludes that, with regard to two contentious rulings made by the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia regarding the 2024 elections, divergent viewpoints have no bearing on the rule of law but do have an effect on judges' individual authority and can provoke public discussion. The contrasting viewpoints expressed in dissenting opinions contribute to a richer legal discourse, particularly when it comes to the significance of substantive and procedural justice in Indonesian elections. This study recommends that the nomination, determination, and selection of judges for the constitutional court be carried out in a transparent, responsible manner that takes into account increased public involvement in an effort to preserve legal sovereignty while defending the ideals and principles of democracy. Rather than going via a political process rife with interests that diminish the court's authority and credibility as a stand-alone judicial body

Keywords


Constitutional Court, constitution, election, election result dispute, Indonesia.

Full Text:

PDF

References


Amarini, Indriati. 2020. "Implementation of Verdict Based on Pancasila Values in Indonesia BT - Proceedings of the International Conference on Law, Economics and Health (ICLEH 2020)." In , 697-700. Atlantis Press. https://doi.org/10.2991/aebmr.k.200513.132.

anticorruption.org. 2017. "Poor Ethics of Constitutional Judges | ICW." 2017. https://antikorupsi.org/en/article/poor-ethics-constitutional-judges.

apnews. 2023. "Court Panel Removes Indonesia's Chief Justice for Ethical Breach That Benefited President's Son | AP News." 2023. https://apnews.com/article/indonesia-constitutional-court-dismiss-chief-justice-4223047fb46310ffd2c7dfa0bad5b558.

Baidhowah, Adfin. 2021. "Defender of Democracy: The Role of the Indonesian Constitutional Court in Preventing Rapid Democratic Backsliding." In. https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:236404252.

Basin, David A, Sasa Radomirovic, and Lara Schmid. 2020. "Dispute Resolution in Voting." 2020 IEEE 33rd Computer Security Foundations Symposium (CSF), 1-16. https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:218571305.

Bima, M R, and Muhammad Rinaldy Bima. 2022. "The Dispute on Determination of the General Election Commission Members: A Study of Administrative Effort Implementation." SIGn Law Journal 4 (2): 277–90. https://doi.org/10.37276/SJH.V4I2.163.

bpk.go.id. 2003. "Law No. 24 Year 2003." 2003. https://peraturan.bpk.go.id/Details/44069/uu-no-24-tahun-2003.

---. 2004. "Law No. 5 Year 2004." 2004. https://peraturan.bpk.go.id/Details/40491/uu-no-5-tahun-2004.

---. 2009. "Law No. 48 of 2009." 2009. https://peraturan.bpk.go.id/Details/38793/uu-no-48-tahun-2009.

Bryan, Amanda C, and Eve M Ringsmuth. 2016. "Jeremiad or Weapon of Words? The Power of Emotive Language in Supreme Court Dissents." Journal of Law and Courts 4 (1): 159-85. https://doi.org/DOI: 10.1086/684788.

Butt, Simon. 2018. "The Function of Judicial Dissent in Indonesia's Constitutional Court." Constitutional Review. https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:158048431.

Davis-Roberts, Avery, and David J. Carroll. 2010. "Using International Law to Assess Elections." Democratization 17 (3): 416–41. https://doi.org/10.1080/13510341003700253.

Dichio, Michael A, and Igor Logvinenko. 2024. "'Culture and Practice Eat Documents for Lunch:' Norms and Procedures in the 2020 Election Cases." Law and Policy. https://doi.org/10.1111/lapo.12241.

Eddyono, L W. 2017. "Independence of the Indonesian Constitutional Court in Norms and Practices." Constitutional Review 3 (1): 71–97. https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev314.

Eddyono, Luthfi Widagdo. 2018. "The Constitutional Court and Consolidation of Democracy in Indonesia." In. https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:158874928.

Fauziyah, Fauziyah, and Sri Praptianingsih. 2015. "Dispute Settlement Patterns on the Village Chief Election at Bondowoso Regency." Rechtsidee 2: 11-20. https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:147110284.

Green, Rebecca. 2016. "Arbitrating Ballot Battles." Kentucky Law Journal 104:9. https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:157671633.

Großer, Jens, and Thorsten Giertz. 2024. "Controversy Surrounds Indonesia's Election Results." Games and Economic Behavior. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.geb.2024.02.005.

Hanretty, Chris. 2015. "Judicial Disagreement Need Not Be Political: Dissent on the Estonian Supreme Court." Europe-Asia Studies 67 (6): 970–88. https://doi.org/10.1080/09668136.2015.1054260.

Harijanti, Susi Dwi, and Tim Lindsey. 2006. "Indonesia: General Elections Test the Amended Constitution and the New Constitutional Court." International Journal of Constitutional Law 4 (1): 138 - 150. https://doi.org/10.1093/icon/moi055.

Hasen, Richard L. 2012. The Voting Wars: From Florida 2000 to the next Election Meltdown. The Voting Wars: From Florida 2000 to the Next Election Meltdown. https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-84902736684&partnerID=40&md5=07042efd7bea4b9e5490755bd7bff63d.

Hogg, Peter W., and Ravi Amarnath. 2017. "Why Judges Should Dissent." Https://Doi.Org/10.3138/UTLJ.4216 67 (2): 126–41. https://doi.org/10.3138/UTLJ.4216.

Ibrahim, M. 2022. "Does the Indonesian Judicial Review System Need Reform?" Australian Journal of Asian Law 22 (1): 17–33. https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85160518241&partnerID=40&md5=c4e5d9f303dfd3d37d99fb2921301c8b.

Indra, Mexsasai, Geofani Milthree Saragih, and Tito Handoko. 2023. "Pseudo-Judicial Review for the Dispute over the Result of the Regional Head Election in Indonesia." Lentera Hukum 10 (1): 111 - 134. https://doi.org/10.19184/ejlh.v10i1.36685.

Ipp, Oren, and Terence F. Hoverter. 2005. "Identifying International Principles for Resolving Election Disputes." Administrative Law Review 57. https://heinonline.org/HOL/Page?handle=hein.journals/admin57&id=855&div=&collection=.

Karjoko, L, L.T.A.L. Wardhani, S Marwiyah, I Gusti Ayu Ketut Rachmi Handayani, A K Jaelani, A Tahir, and S Al-Fatih. 2020. "Problems of Democratic and Dignified Election in Indonesian Simultaneously Electoral Era." International Journal of Criminology and Sociology 9: 1701-8. https://doi.org/10.6000/1929-4409.2020.09.193.

Karpenko, Konstantin V. 2021. "DISSENTING OPINION IN THE CONSTITUTIONAL JUSTICE AND THE EVOLUTION OF LEGAL SCIENCE." Tyumen State University Herald. Social, Economic, and Law Research. https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:245947623.

Klein, Ben. 2017. "A Vote for Clarity: Establishing a Federal Test for Intervention in Election-Related Disputes." Fordham Law Review 86 (3): 1361 – 1391. https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85040735129&partnerID=40&md5=73d34aa0bd31a6886b3178a544cc209e.

Kusadarini, Eny, Anang Priyanto, and Sri Hartini. 2021. "The Process and Role of the Judiciary in Election Administration Dispute Resolution in Indonesia." Journal of Civics: Media for Civic Studies. https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:244206819.

Madril, Oce. 2020. "THE AUTHORITY OF ADMINISTRATIVE COURT IN SETTLING THE DISPUTES OVER ELECTION PROCESS IN INDONESIA." In. https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:219135852.

Martin, Ross. 2020. "The 2020 Electoral End Game - Finding a Peaceful Transition of Power in a Political Question World." SSRN Electronic Journal, August. https://doi.org/10.2139/SSRN.3668583.

Meylina, U, and R Ritonga. 2021. "FROM STATE SOVEREIGNTY TO PEOPLE SOVEREIGNTY: A CASE STUDY OF INDONESIA'S CONSTITUTIONAL COURT." Journal of Legal, Ethical and Regulatory Issues 24 (7): 1-13. https://www.scopus.com/inward/record.uri?eid=2-s2.0-85112663638&partnerID=40&md5=dab155085c650f3ca5ca763a84c5aa71.

Misztal-Konecka, Joanna. 2023. "Separate and Dissenting Judicial Opinions and Their Significance for a Democratic Society. Reflections Against the Background of Polish Law." Archiwum Filozofii Prawa i Filozofii Spolecznej 35 (2): 43–52. https://doi.org/10.36280//AFPIFS.2023.2.43.

mkri.id. 2015. "HISTORY OF THE CONSTITUTIONAL COURT | Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia." 2015. https://www.mkri.id/index.php?page=web.Berita&id=11766.

---. 2023. "DECISION Number 90/PUU-XXI/2023." 2023. https://www.mkri.id/public/content/persidangan/putusan/putusan_mkri_9332_1697427438.pdf.

---. 2024. "Decision of the Constitutional Court of the Republic of Indonesia." 2024. https://www.mkri.id/index.php?page=web.Putusan&id=1&kat=1&menu=5.

mkri. 2023. "55 PUU 2023." 2023.

Mozaffar, Shaheen, and Andreas Schedler. 2002. "The Comparative Study of Electoral Governance-Introduction." International Political Science Review 23 (1): 5–27. https://doi.org/10.1177/0192512102023001001.

Muro, Sergio, Sofia Amaral-Garcia, Alejandro Chehtman, and Nuno Garoupa. 2020. "Exploring Dissent in the Supreme Court of Argentina." International Review of Law and Economics 63: 105909. https://doi.org/https://doi.org/10.1016/j.irle.2020.105909.

NORRIS, PIPPA. 2017. Why American Elections Are Flawed (And How to Fix Them). 1st ed. Cornell University Press. http://www.jstor.org/stable/10.7591/j.ctt1n7qkxz.

Omara, A. 2017. "The Indonesian Constitutional Court and the Democratic Institutions in Judicial Review." Constitutional Review 3 (2): 189–207. https://doi.org/10.31078/consrev323.

Parker, Christopher M., and Benjamin W. Woodson. 2020. "Normative Preferences and Responses to Dissension on the U.S. Supreme Court." Justice System Journal 41 (3): 220–43. https://doi.org/10.1080/0098261X.2020.1768186.

Passos, Nélson R S, Ariel F Rodrigues, Hendrik T MacEdo, Bruno O P Prado, Gilton J F Da Silva, and Leonardo N Matos. 2019. "Open Data Extraction, Transformation, and Loading as a Tool for Supporting 2018 Elections' Voters; [Extração, Transformação e Carga de Dados Abertos Como Ferramenta de Apoio Ao Voto Nas Eleições De]." In ACM International Conference Proceeding Series. https://doi.org/10.1145/3330204.3330232.

Rannie, M, R Saraswati, and F Wisnaeni. 2024. "Does the Reform of the Parliamentary and Presidential Threshold Strengthen the Presidential System in Indonesia?" Sriwijaya Law Review 8 (1): 133–51. https://doi.org/10.28946/slrev.Vol8.Iss1.3157.pp133-151.

Renberg, K M. 2020. "The Impact of Retention Systems on Judicial Behavior: A Synthetic Controls Analysis of State Supreme Courts." Justice System Journal 41 (4): 292–312. https://doi.org/10.1080/0098261X.2020.1843093.

Rice, Douglas R. 2017. "Issue Divisions and US Supreme Court Decision Making." Journal of Politics 79 (1): 210–22. https://doi.org/10.1086/687540/SUPPL_FILE/150554APPENDIX.PDF.

Salam, Alaa Foaud, and Saab Naji Aboud. 2023. "Dismissing the Judicial Claim in the Administrative Lawsuit." Journal of Namibian Studies: History Politics Culture. https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:259387854.

Salman, Radian, and Rosa Ristawati. 2020. "Constitutional Dialogue in the Indonesian Election Law: Tension between the Indonesian Constitutional Court and the Legislature," December, 156-62. https://doi.org/10.5220/0010052701560162.

Simanjuntak, Louis Fernando, Elis Rusmiati, and Budi Arta Atmaja. 2023. "Dissenting Opinion of Corruption Court Judges as a Form of Freedom and Legal Reform in Indonesia." Corruptio. https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:266513022.

Sulistyowati, T, and A Satrio. 2023. "Strengthening the Legitimacy of the Indonesian Constitutional Court Decision through Supermajority Requirement: Lesson from the South Korean Experience." Revista de Investigacoes Constitucionais 10 (3). https://doi.org/10.5380/rinc.v10i3.89341.

Sullivan, Kathleen. 2023. "234 Pages of Sworn Affidavits: Legalism Without Politics in the Attempt to Overthrow the 2020 Election." New Political Science 45 (2): 224-238. https://doi.org/10.1080/07393148.2023.2203063.

tempo. 2023. "A Court That Has Lost Its Dignity - Opinion En.Tempo.Co." 2023. https://en.tempo.co/read/1789719/a-court-that-has-lost-its-dignity.

thediplomat. 2023. "An Indonesian Constitutional Court Scandal and an Election in Jeopardy - The Diplomat." 2023. https://thediplomat.com/2023/11/an-indonesian-constitutional-court-scandal-and-an-election-in-jeopardy/.

theguardian. 2023. "Joko Widodo's Son Can Run for Indonesian Vice-President after Controversial Court Ruling | Joko Widodo | The Guardian." 2023. https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2023/oct/17/joko-widodos-son-can-run-for-indonesian-vice-president-after-controversial-court-ruling.

Varsava, Nina. 2018. "The Role of Dissents in the Formation of Precedent." SSRN Electronic Journal, September. https://doi.org/10.2139/SSRN.3094016.

Vass, H. 2017. "The Role of Hedging in Balancing Power and Persuasion in the Judicial Context: The Case of Majority and Dissenting Opinions." In Power, Persuasion and Manipulation in Specialized Genres: Providing Keys to the Rhetoric of Professional Communities, 227-41. https://doi.org/10.3726/b11481.

Widodo, Heru. 2021. "The Interpretation of Structured, Systematic, and Massive Violations in the 2019 Presidential Election Dispute at the Indonesian Constitutional Court." Journal of Politics and Law. https://api.semanticscholar.org/CorpusID:237743146.

Williams, Kieran. 2007. "The Growing Litigiousness of Czech Elections." Europe - Asia Studies 59 (6): 937 - 959. https://doi.org/10.1080/09668130701489147.




DOI: https://doi.org/10.33373/jtp.v10i1.8997

Refbacks

  • There are currently no refbacks.


EDITORIAL OFFICE:

Department of Government Science, Faculty of Social and Political Sciences - Universitas Riau Kepulauan - Indonesia

Telp: (0778) 39275 | Email: jurnaltriaspolitika2017@gmail.com

Jurnal Trias Politika (JTP) is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License. © 2017-2025 Authors